Townhome, condominium, and other homeowner associations are typically part of what is called a common interest community, or CIC. Ownership in a CIC offers an opportunity for home ownership without many of the added day-to-day responsibilities, such as snow removal or yard maintenance. In a CIC, owners are members in an association comprised of all owners in the community. The association, through its board of directors, administers the CIC, which includes setting and enforcing rules regarding the use and operation of the community and the individual units. An association may be organized in the form of a profit, nonprofit, or cooperative organization, but CICs are generally controlled by the Minnesota Common Interest Ownership Act (“MCIOA”), Chapter 515B of Minnesota Statutes, and the association’s governing documents (i.e., declaration, bylaws, articles of incorporation, and rules and regulations). Depending on when a particular CIC was formed and its governing documents, Chapters 515 or 515A may also apply to particular circumstances. It is important to understand, however, that while many associations operate under the basic framework provided in MCIOA or other applicable statutes, an association’s governing documents provide specific provisions for the operation of the association and may differ in some respects from the statute. The declaration and bylaws control unless they are inconsistent with MCOIA. Be sure to carefully review an association’s governing documents before purchasing a unit in a CIC.
MCIOA requires that a seller of a unit in a CIC provide certain information to a prospective buyer prior to a sale, including the declaration and any amendments; bylaws, articles of incorporation, and rules and regulations; a disclosure statement or resale disclosure certificate; the most recent financial statement; and current budget; as well as inform the prospective purchaser of any outstanding judgments or lawsuits pending against the association (see Minn. Stat. § 515B). A purchaser has ten days after receiving the disclosures to cancel the purchase agreement, unless the disclosures were made more than ten days before the purchase agreement was signed or the right was waived by the buyer in writing.
Powers and Responsibilities of the Association
A CIC association must be governed by a board of directors, which is generally elected by the association’s unit owners. However, the declaration creating the association may provide that the declarant (typically the developer or builder) control the association for a period of time. This period will generally begin on the date the CIC was created and end at the earliest of several possible events, such as five years after the declarant first conveys a unit to someone else or when 75 percent of the units are sold. At the end of the declarant control, the unit owners must elect the board. When the unit owners elect the board of directors, they expect that the board will operate the association and preserve, enhance, and protect the value of the CIC. While the association’s governing documents will specify the board’s exact powers, the board generally has powers to administer the CIC, including the powers specified in Minn. Stat. § 515B.3-102. These powers include making, amending, or revoking rules and regulations for the CIC and its units, including regulating the use of the common areas and units, the appearance of the CIC, and regulating or prohibiting animals. Accordingly, an association board may be able to prohibit or limit smoking, enact parking regulations, adopt regulations regarding pet ownership, or even limit the use of bird feeders. This is a substantial difference from owning a free-standing home and is an important consideration when buying a unit in a CIC. The board also adopts the budget and levies assessments, hires agents and contractors, and otherwise operates the CIC. Associations are generally responsible for the maintenance, repair, and replacement of common elements and are required to maintain property and liability insurance “to the extent reasonably available” (see Minn. Stat. §§ 515B.3-107, -113). Owners, however, are responsible for the maintenance and repair of their units and any damage to the common elements caused by them or their guests (see Minn. Stat. § 515B.3-107(a)). Also, associations may assess common expenses benefiting less than all units against just the units that are benefitted (see Minn. Stat. § 515B.3-115(e)(2)). It is important to read the association’s governing documents carefully and understand the insurance coverage provided by the association as well as the association’s responsibilities regarding maintenance and repair. Sometimes, there is damage to an element not specifically defined in the declarations or damage to external elements that causes damage inside a unit, resulting in a dispute over who is responsible. Owners should also be aware that an association is typically entitled to have access to each unit to perform maintenance or repairs and to correct or abate certain conditions.
Associations bill the unit owners for their share of the CIC’s expenses. These charges are typically called assessments or dues. Regular assessments are needed for the day-to-day operation and long-term expenses of the association. The board must budget for adequate reserve funds and replacement reserves to cover the replacement of the CIC’s common elements. Ideally, these assessments are sufficient to pay the bills for the services and goods contemplated in the budget. If, however, the regular assessments collected are insufficient, the board may levy special assessments for emergency or unbudgeted expenses or to replenish underfunded replacement reserves. Associations may also assess unit owners with the cost to repair damage caused by the owners or their guests. And, associations may levy fines against owners for violating the rules, bylaws, or declaration. Such fines, however, can only be levied after giving the owner notice and an opportunity to be heard before the board. If assessments are not timely paid, the association can charge interest and late charges. It may also charge reasonable attorney’s fees and any collection costs incurred in collecting past due assessments, which may substantially increase the amount owed. The assessments and related charges are automatically liens on the owner’s unit. To collect the assessments, the association may hire an attorney, collection agency, or foreclosure service. The association may obtain a personal judgment or foreclose on its lien and take an owner’s unit. A foreclosure of an association lien is just like a mortgage foreclosure (or in certain cooperatives, like the foreclosure of a security interest). This Office has prepared a brochure entitled Facing Mortgage Foreclosure
, which provides information on the general foreclosure process. By paying a fair share of the obligations of the association, through the budget and assessment process, the owners are proportionally paying for the current and long-term maintenance obligations of the association. It is imperative that all owners pay their assessments in a timely manner as the failure by several owners to pay their assessments could place the association in financial jeopardy.
Often an association board will contract with a professional management company to run the day-to-day affairs of the association. Ultimately, however, the board is responsible for the oversight of the association, and it answers to the unit owners. The management company is a separate business enterprise usually hired, at a cost, to act as the agent of the association. As an agent of the association, the management company takes direction from the board. The managing agent may collect assessments, pay the association’s bills, enforce rule infractions as instructed by the board, and obtain various vendors to perform services. Management companies may also assist with the budget process, prepare meeting agendas and minutes for the board, or serve as a neutral third party to help solve problems that can occur in CICs.
Rights of Owners
Access to Documents
Minnesota law requires associations to keep certain records and make them available for inspection by any unit owner or their agent (see Minn. Stat. § 515B.3-118). Such records include membership records; all meeting records; financial records; association contracts, leases, and agreements; and material correspondence. Associations do not need to make available information that was the basis for a closed board meeting under MCIOA. Additional document access provisions may also be found in the particular statute under which the association was formed. The Minnesota Nonprofit Corporation Act, for example, grants access for members and directors to certain documents and provides a claim for injunctive and other relief for anyone wrongfully denied access. Keep in mind that an owner may be required to pay copy fees if he or she wishes to copy any documents.
Owners have a right to be kept informed about their association. Associations must prepare an annual report and provide a copy to each unit owner prior to or at the association’s annual owner meeting (see Minn. Stat. § 515B.3-106(b)(2)). The annual report must contain, at a minimum, revenue and expense statements, capital expenditures, a replacement reserves statement, the status of any pending litigation or judgments, and a description of insurance coverage provided by the association.
Claim for Relief
MCIOA establishes a claim for relief for those who are adversely affected when a declarant, association or any other person violates MCIOA or the association’s governing documents (see Minn. Stat. § 515B.4-116). This claim is in addition to any other rights, remedies, or claims owners may have under other statutes or common law. Also, the statute under which the association was formed or incorporated may provide additional relief. For example, the Minnesota Nonprofit Corporation Act authorizes directors and members with voting rights to bring an action or petition the court for relief under certain circumstances. It should be noted however, that because associations are funded by owners, costs incurred by a board while defending a lawsuit initiated by its owners may be assessed back to the owners. Also, under MCIOA, the court may award attorney’s fees and cost to the prevailing party. As such, if the association prevails, the opposing owner or owners may be responsible for the association’s fees as well as their own.
Tips for Addressing Problems in a Condominium or Townhome Association
Contact the Board of Directors
The first step to address problems with your CIC association is to notify the board of your concerns. Although an association may hire agents such as a management company, the board governs the association and should be aware of issues and concerns that involve the community. Thus, if you seek particular information or have an issue with your CIC, make the board aware of the matter. If it withholds information or does not respond, ask the board under what authority it is acting.
Attend Meetings and Participate
Many decisions regarding the association’s operation are made through the majority vote of owners at association meetings. Minnesota law requires that an association meeting be held at least annually, and special meetings may also be called. Accordingly, to make your voice heard, you should attend meetings and cast your vote on issues, including electing the board.
Talk to Other Owners
Because an association is comprised of the unit owners, you may find that you can accomplish a great deal simply by speaking with others in your association about your concerns or ideas. Other concerned owners may be willing to join you in contacting the board or may help determine whether other action is necessary.
If your dispute with the association involves an amount less than the $15,000 maximum judgment allowed in conciliation court, you may wish to consider filing a claim in conciliation court, also known as small claims court. This Office has prepared a brochure entitled Conciliation Court: A User’s Guide to Small Claims Court
, which provides information regarding filing a claim in conciliation court.
Contact a Private Attorney
If other methods do not accomplish the desired result, you may wish to speak with a private attorney about your concerns. The laws affecting CIC associations can be complicated, and a private attorney familiar with these laws is in the best position to advise you of your legal rights and potential avenues of recourse. For more information concerning CICs, you may wish to contact the following organizations: